5 Strategies to Reduce Time-to-Hire Without Sacrificing Quality

Time-to-hire is a critical metric for recruiting teams. A lengthy hiring process can mean losing top candidates to competitors. Here are five proven strategies to speed things up without compromising quality.

1. Streamline Your Screening Process

The Problem: Initial phone screens often take 30-45 minutes per candidate, and you might need to screen 20+ people per role.

The Solution: Use AI-powered tools to handle initial screening. This can reduce screening time by 60%+ while ensuring consistent evaluation criteria.

2. Implement Structured Interviews

The Problem: Unstructured interviews are time-consuming and often don’t predict success.

The Solution:

• Create standardized question sets
• Use scorecards for consistent evaluation
• Train interviewers on best practices

This makes decisions faster and more objective.

3. Optimize Your Interview Schedule

The Problem: Coordinating schedules across multiple interviewers creates delays.

The Solution:

• Block out dedicated interview slots
• Use automated scheduling tools
• Consider panel interviews to reduce total time

4. Make Decisions Quickly

The Problem: Delays between interview stages lose candidates.

The Solution:

• Set SLAs for each stage (e.g., feedback within 24 hours)
• Establish clear decision-making criteria upfront
• Empower hiring managers to make offers promptly

5. Leverage Technology Integration

The Problem: Manual data entry and switching between tools wastes time.

The Solution:

• Integrate your ATS with screening tools
• Automate candidate communications
• Use dashboards to track pipeline progress

Real-World Impact

Companies implementing these strategies typically see:

• 40-50% reduction in time-to-hire
• Higher offer acceptance rates (faster processes retain candidate interest)
• Better candidate experience (reduced frustration and uncertainty)

Getting Started

You don’t need to implement everything at once. Start with your biggest bottleneck:

• If screening takes too long → Consider AI-powered pre-screening
• If scheduling is difficult → Implement automated scheduling
• If decisions drag → Set clear timelines and criteria

Measuring Success

Track these metrics to measure improvement:

• Average time-to-hire by role
• Candidate drop-off rates by stage
• Time spent on screening vs. final interviews
• Offer acceptance rates

---

Want to see how AI screening can reduce your time-to-hire? Hire Malia to get started.